Skip to main content

Deliciously dreamy and creamy Layered peanut butter & caramel cake (with cream cheese icing!)

Peanut butter + salted caramel = a delicious dream come true, especially when it comes in layers of creamy and sticky goodness. Here’s a peanut butter and caramel cake recipe (with peanut butter and cream cheese icing of course!) that carries the nostalgia of childhood sweets while elevating peanut butter to the height of baked confection.

Peanut butter and caramel cake

What you'll need

Prep time: 30 mins | Cook time : 25 mins | Makes 1 large cake

For the cake:

For the salted caramel:

For the peanut butter icing:

Peanut brittle, chocolate covered peanuts, etc: to decorate.

New Arrivals in Cake Stands & Tiered Stands

Method:

  1. To make the cake, preheat the oven to 180°C.
  2. Line and grease 3 round cake tins (18cm or 20cm will work well for this type of layered cake).
  3. Beat the eggs and sugar until pale and fluffy.
  4. Heat the milk and butter until the butter has just melted, remove from the heat and add the peanut butter and vanilla.
  5. Mix the flour, salt and baking powder together.
  6. Fold the flour mixture into the beaten eggs and sugar mixture, alternately adding some of the hot peanut butter milk mixture. Make sure not to make the mixture too dry by adding too much flour at a time.
  7. Spoon equal amounts of the batter into each of your three cake tins. Place in the oven and bake for 20–25 minutes until golden brown and springy to the touch. (Don’t be tempted to take the cake out of the oven before the time is up. The cake will brown a fair bit due to high sugar content, but still needs the allotted time to cook through properly.) Remove and leave to cool completely.

Peanut butter cake with icing

  1. To make the peanut butter icing, beat the peanut butter and cream cheese together until soft.
  2. Add the vanilla and icing sugar, mix together, then add in the sour cream and beat well.
  3. For the salted caramel, stir the sea salt through the caramel in a separate bowl.
  4. To assemble the cake, place one of your cake layers on the cake stand and ice with a layer of salted caramel icing, followed by peanut butter cream cheese icing. Place the next cake layer on top of that and repeat the icing process and again with the third layer. You can be as haphazard or neat as you like. If you know you’ll have to move the cake a lot (to take it to a party or to work), stick a couple of wooden skewers through the layers of the cake (cut the tops off so they don’t stick out) to keep them from sliding around — just try to remember where they are for when you cut the cake. And remember, icing a cake in hot weather can lead to a slippery mess, so keep your kitchen extra cool while you work and refrigerate the cake layers to make sure the icing doesn’t melt when applied.
  5. Swirl your top layer of icing together a bit to create a marbled pattern and finally, top with peanut brittle, chocolate peanuts and any other decorative bits that call out to you.

Peanut butter cake brittle

You can also experiment with a different kind of nut butter! This cake makes for a beautiful autumnal centrepiece for any gathering and definitely needs a large pot of coffee to accompany it.

Peanut butter cake finished

We’re pretty sure your cake stand will look like this after your guests have left. And that’s a good thing.

Inspired to get baking?

Sagenwolf's Non-Stick Bakeware's got everything you need! From non-stick cake pans and loaf tins to cooling racks and tart pans.

Items in Your Cart

Account

Log Out
Close